top of page

Navigating State Lines: Contrasting New York and Florida Wills



Estate planning is a vital process that varies not only from individual to individual but also from state to state. For those split between the bustling streets of New York and the sun-soaked shores of Florida, understanding the key distinctions between a New York will and a Florida will is paramount. In this article, I'll highlight some of the nuances to help you navigate the unique legal landscapes of these two states. And when you are ready to discuss your estate plan, please call or email me. Trying to craft your own legal documents can result in disaster for your loved ones.


New York Wills: Urban Precision

1. Formalities:

  • New York requires specific formalities for a valid will, including the need for two witnesses to sign in the presence of the testator (the person creating the will).

  • Handwritten or holographic wills are generally not recognized, emphasizing the importance of a properly executed document.

2. Probate Process:

  • New York’s probate process can be meticulous, involving court supervision and potentially leading to a longer duration for the distribution of assets.

  • The probate court oversees the validation of the will and the appointment of the executor to carry out the testator’s wishes.

3. Elective Share:

  • New York has an “elective share” law that allows a surviving spouse to claim a portion of the deceased spouse’s estate, even if the will attempts to disinherit them.


Florida Wills: Sunshine State Simplicity

1. Formalities:

  • Florida, in contrast, recognizes both witnessed and handwritten wills, offering more flexibility in the creation of a valid will.

  • While witnesses are still required, Florida allows “self-proving” wills, simplifying the probate process.

2. Probate Process:

  • Florida’s probate process is generally considered more streamlined compared to New York, often leading to quicker asset distribution.

  • The court may grant “summary administration” for smaller estates, expediting the process further.

3. Homestead Exemption:

  • Florida boasts a unique homestead exemption, protecting a surviving spouse and certain heirs from the forced sale of a primary residence.

Choosing the Right Fit:

1. Residency Considerations:

  • If you split your time between New York and Florida, consider your primary residence when creating your will, as this will likely determine the applicable state laws.

2. Legal Assistance:

  • Consulting with legal professionals in each state is crucial to ensure your will complies with the specific requirements and nuances of the respective jurisdictions.

3. Family Dynamics:

  • Understanding how each state handles family provisions, elective shares, and homestead exemptions is essential for tailoring your will to your family’s needs.


In sum, whether you’re weaving through the skyscrapers of New York or basking in the Florida sunshine, crafting a will that aligns with the legal intricacies of your chosen state is imperative. Legal counsel familiar with the nuances of each jurisdiction can guide you through the process, ensuring that your final wishes are documented and executed seamlessly, no matter where life takes you. That is where I come in. Admitted to the bar in both New York and Florida, I can help you ensure your legacy is protected. Contact me to create the right estate plan for you.

Call or email today for a free consultation.
  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Twitter Icon

The Law Office of Robert Corbett, Esq., P.C.
rob@robcorbettlaw.com

New York City Office

40 Wall Street, 52nd Floor  |  New York, NY 10005

(646) 770-1529  |  (646) 430-8548 Fax

Florida Office

1635 E. Highway 50, Suite 300 Clermont, FL 34711

(352) 234-4170‬

© 2019, 2024 Rob Corbett Law, All Rights Reserved. This website is Attorney Advertising.

bottom of page